| Total | partite | Vittorie | Pareggi | Sconfitte | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Total | 952 | 375 | (39%) | 240 | (25%) | 337 | (35%) |
| Casa | 476 | 254 | (53%) | 114 | (24%) | 108 | (23%) |
| Trasferta | 476 | 121 | (25%) | 126 | (26%) | 229 | (48%) |
| Item | Nella competizione | Casa | Ospiti | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Più grande vittoria in casa | Major League Soccer 2001 | Columbus Crew | 6-1 | Tampa Bay Mutiny |
| Major League Soccer 2023 | Columbus Crew | 6-1 | Atlanta United | |
| Major League Soccer 1998 | Columbus Crew | 6-1 | NE Revolution | |
| Major League Soccer 2015 | Columbus Crew | 5-0 | DC United | |
| Più grande vittoria in trasferta | Major League Soccer 1996 | Sporting KC | 1-5 | Columbus Crew |
| Major League Soccer 2002 | Sporting KC | 0-4 | Columbus Crew | |
| Peggiore sconfitta in trasferta | Major League Soccer 2017 | Toronto FC | 5-0 | Columbus Crew |
| Peggiore sconfitta in casa | Major League Soccer 2010 | Columbus Crew | 0-4 | Seattle Sounders |
| Major League Soccer 1996 | Columbus Crew | 0-4 | NY Red Bulls | |
| Major League Soccer 2005 | Columbus Crew | 0-4 | Sporting KC |
